Physeal Injuries in Children Salter-Harris Classification
Physeal Injuries in Children Salter-Harris Classification
Rachel A. Coel
Basics
Description
-
In pediatric bone, the primary areas of growth include the physis and the epiphysis.
-
Physeal injuries may occur in the skeletally immature population from acute trauma, as well as from chronic overuse and repetitive loading.
-
In 1963, Salter and Harris described a classification scheme for acute injuries to the physis (1)[C].
-
Although most physeal fractures heal well, growth plate injuries can lead to complications including avascular necrosis, premature growth arrest, or angular deformities.
Epidemiology
-
Occurs most commonly after 10 yrs of age but can be seen in any skeletally immature patient
-
Typical age range: 10–16 yrs of age; median age: 13 yrs
-
Predominant gender: Boys > Girls
-
Most common time frame: Spring through summer months (more outdoor playtime)
-
Most common bone location: Distal radial physis
-
Most common type of physeal injury: Salter-Harris type II (75%)
Prevalence
Current estimates suggest that from 15–30% of all pediatric fractures involve the physis.
Risk Factors
-
Skeletal immaturity
-
Falls, especially while running or playing
-
Competitive organized sports, especially contact sports
-
Recreational sports, including skiing/snowboarding, skateboarding, and bicycling
-
Overuse training activities that cause repetitive loading and stress, such as gymnastics, cheerleading, throwing, and running
General Prevention
-
Monitor training demands, especially in young athletes during periods of heightened growth
-
Cross-training to avoid overuse and repetition
-
Overtraining prevention: Alternate periods of heavy training with designated periods of rest.
Etiology
-
There are 2 types of epiphyses: Traction epiphyses (apophyses), where major tendons originate or insert into bone, and pressure epiphyses, at the ends of long bones.
-
Traction epiphyses shape and strengthen bone but do not add longitudinal growth; hence their injury typically does not cause longitudinal growth arrest.
-
Pressure epiphyses add longitudinal growth to long bones.
-
The physis, located between the epiphysis and the metaphysis of long bones, serves as the area of rapid longitudinal bone growth.
-
Injury to the physis or pressure epiphyses may result in growth disturbance.
-
The active physis consists of 4 zones of cells separated by cartilage matrix; the 3rd zone (hypertrophic zone) is the area most susceptible to injury and cleavage.
-
The epiphysis provides the nutrient blood supply to the physis; epiphyseal injury can cause disruption of normal growth and maturation owing to compromised vascular supply.
Diagnosis
Salter-Harris classification of epiphyseal plate injuries (1)[C]:
-
Type I: Complete separation of epiphysis from metaphysis without bone fracture
-
Type II: Separation occurs partially along physis and out through an associated metaphyseal bone fracture.
-
Type III: Intraarticular epiphyseal fracture extending out through partially separated physis
-
Type IV: Intraarticular epiphyseal fracture extending through the full thickness of physis and out through metaphyseal bone fracture
-
Type V: Severe crush injury at one area of physis
History
-
Fall onto an outstretched hand (FOOSH) is a common mechanism of distal radius growth plate injury (2)[C].
-
Abduction, adduction, and twisting mechanisms are especially common in tibial physeal injuries and other lower extremity growth plate injuries (1,2)[C].
-
Severe abduction or adduction mechanisms in the ankle or knee can cause type V crush injury to the physis (1,2)[C].
-
Patient often reports “sprain” of a joint.
-
Chronic stress injuries to the physis may present with a history of intense training with minimal rest or with overuse repetitive motion, such as baseball pitchers or gymnasts. Patients complain of focal pain at the area of the physis (2,3,4)[C].
Physical Exam
-
Swelling
-
Ecchymosis
-
Focal tenderness to palpation
-
Limited range of motion owing to pain
-
Refusal to bear weight
Diagnostic Tests & Interpretation
Salter-Harris type I injuries are often a clinical diagnosis owing to the radiolucent nature of physis on radiographs.
Imaging
-
Initial approach:
-
Plain x-ray trauma series: Typically 3–4 views of injured joint (anteroposterior, lateral, and oblique) (4)[C]
-
Type I fractures and chronic stress injuries may appear as physeal widening, epiphyseal displacement, or irregularity and sclerosis at the metaphysis; however, no radiographic abnormality is common (3,4)[C].
-
Comparative plain films of the opposite side may be helpful (4)[C].
-
Stress radiography may worsen physeal injury and should be used with caution (2,4)[C].
-
Type II–IV fractures are usually evident on plain x-rays and demonstrate associated bone fracture lines or bone fragmentation (Thurston-Holland sign) (1,2,3)[C].
-
Evaluate fractures for angulation and displacement.
-
-
Follow-up:
-
Growth recovery lines, or Harris lines, appear in the metaphysis on plain films typically 12 wks after trauma (4)[C].
-
If they are parallel to the epiphysis and extend entirely across the metaphysis, future growth disturbance is unlikely.
-
If they are angled, curved, or highly irregular, subsequent growth disturbance is more likely.
-
-
Special considerations:
-
If growth plate injury is suspected but plain radiographs are negative, advanced diagnostic measures may be employed.
-
Further evaluation typically is advocated only if initial management of the injury will be altered by definitive radiographic diagnosis (2)[C].
-
MRI: Preferred method; can identify intact versus separated growth plate, physeal bridging, growth arrest, and avascular necrosis, as well as cartilage, ligamentous/tendinous, and soft tissue imaging (4,5)[C].
-
CT scan: Useful in further defining known physeal injuries and aids in treatment planning, such as alignment and displacement of fractures at the articular surface, growth arrest, physeal bridging, and surgical planning (4,5)[C].
-
Other options include US and bone scintigraphy (2,5)[C].
-
P.467
Differential Diagnosis
-
Bone fractures
-
Sprains: Physeal injuries most commonly mistaken for sprains
-
Ligamentous rupture
-
Dislocation
Treatment
ED Treatment
-
Nondisplaced or minimally displaced type I and II fractures: Splint immobilization, ice, elevation, and orthopedic referral (2)[C]
-
Type III and IV fractures: Obtain orthopedic consultation in ED owing to intra-articular fracture (2)[C].
-
If diagnosed in ED, type V fractures require orthopedic consultation (2)[C].
Medication
Pain management should be addressed (OTC versus prescription pain medications).
Additional Treatment
General Measures
-
Diagnosed type I fractures: Closed reduction and rigid immobilization (cast versus brace) for 3–4 wks
-
Suspected type I fractures: Immobilization for 1–2 wks; then reexamination and repeat radiographs for periosteal reaction. If healing reaction is evident, immobilize for 1–2 more wks.
-
Type II fractures: Typically closed reduction and rigid immobilization with casting for 3–4 wks; if unstable, refer to orthopedic surgery.
-
Type III and IV fractures: Refer to orthopedic surgery; often require open reduction and internal fixation to ensure stability and joint surface congruity (1)[C].
-
Diagnosed type V fractures: Non-weight-bearing cast for 3–4 wks followed by another 2–3 wks of weight-bearing casting; refer to orthopedic surgery (1,4)[C].
-
Late-diagnosis type V fractures: Frequently a missed diagnosis acutely and diagnosed after growth disturbance has occurred; refer to orthopedic surgery (5)[C].
-
Multiple attempts at reduction and reductions performed 7 days after the date of injury are not recommended owing to increased risk of physeal injury (1)[C].
-
Consider bracing for sports activity for another 3–4 wks after initial rigid immobilization is complete and while the patient is in rehabilitation.
Additional Therapies
Consider physical therapy prior to return to play for ankle and knee physeal injuries.
Surgery/Other Procedures
May be required for significantly displaced or unstable type I or type II fractures or, more commonly, for intraarticular type III and IV fractures
Ongoing Care
Follow-Up Recommendations
Consider bracing for sports activity for another 3–4 wks after initial rigid immobilization is complete.
Patient Monitoring
-
Patients should be monitored for growth disturbance or deformity every 6 mos for the 1st yr after physeal injury.
-
Thereafter, patients should be reevaluated annually until skeletal maturity owing to risk of growth disturbance complications until adolescent growth spurt has been completed.
Patient Education
Patients and their parents should be informed of the risk of complications with growth plate injury, including late-onset avascular necrosis, growth arrest, or deformity.
Prognosis
-
Estimates range from 30–75% of all physeal injuries lead to some type of growth disturbance or angular deformity (1,3,4)[C].
-
However, current estimates predict only 1–10% of these patients demonstrate significant functional deficits requiring surgical intervention (4,5)[C].
-
Typically, Salter-Harris type I and II fractures have a good to excellent prognosis. Types III and IV have a poorer prognosis, and type V injury invariably results in growth disturbance with the worst prognosis (1,2,4,5)[C].
-
Younger children have a worse prognosis owing to longer duration of remaining growth that may be affected (1)[C].
-
Other indicators of poor prognosis include compromised epiphyseal blood supply, repeated or forceful manipulation of physis during reduction, and open physeal fracture (1)[C].
Complications
-
Partial or complete growth arrest/limb-length discrepancy
-
Fibrous bone bar/physeal bridging
-
Angular deformity
-
Avascular necrosis
-
Regardless of age of onset of physeal injury, growth disturbances may not manifest until the adolescent growth spurt (5)[C].
-
Risk of complications (3,5)[C]:
-
Greatest risk in early adolescence (pubescence) during periods of rapid growth
-
Increases with higher grade acute Salter-Harris injury (types III–V) (type V has nearly 100% focal growth arrest rate)
-
Increases with high-velocity, high-energy injury
-
Increases in lower extremity injury, especially distal femur, proximal tibia, and distal tibia
-
Also may occur with chronic repetitive stress injury to physis
-
References
1. Salter RB, Harris WR. Injuries involving the epiphyseal plate. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1963;45: 587–622.
2. Perron AD, Miller MD, Brady WJ. Orthopedic pitfalls in the ED: pediatric growth plate injuries. Am J Emerg Med. 2002;20:50–54.
3. Caine D, Difiori J, Maffulli N. Physeal injuries in children's and youth sports: reasons for concern? Br J Sports Med. 2006.
4. Rogers LF, Poznanski AK. Imaging of epiphyseal injuries. Radiology. 1994;191:297–308.
5. Khoshhal KI, Kiefer GN. Physeal bridge resection. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2005;13:47–58.
See Also
-
Calcaneal apophysitis (Sever disease)
-
Osgood-Schlatter disease
Codes
ICD9
-
813.42 Other closed fractures of distal end of radius (alone)
-
821.22 Fracture of lower epiphysis of femur, closed
-
824.8 Unspecified fracture of ankle, closed
Clinical Pearls
-
The Salter-Harris classification system of physeal injuries in children describes growth plate injuries by the level of involvement of the physis, the bone, and the joint.
-
Growth plate injury can occur from both acute trauma and chronic stress.
-
Although most physeal injuries have a favorable prognosis, up to 10% may result in significant growth arrest, angular deformity, or avascular necrosis.
-
There are numerous prognostic indicators, such as age at onset of injury, location of injury, and severity of injury.
-
Orthopedic surgery consultation is recommended for unstable, displaced, or angulated fractures.