Nursemaid’s Elbow
Nursemaid's Elbow
John Munyak
Masha Diede
Basics
Description
-
Results from a traumatic subluxation of the radial head, which is produced by sudden forcible traction on the pronated hand or wrist with the relaxed elbow extended
-
Subluxation of the radial head only occurs in pronation, which is the position in which the diameter of the radial head is the most narrow in the anteroposterior plane.
-
As the radial head subluxes, there is an interposition of the annular ligament in the radiocapitellar joint where it becomes entrapped.
-
Synonym(s): Pulled elbow; Radiocapitellar subluxation; Subluxation of the head of the radius; Subluxation of the radius by elongation; Temper tantrum elbow; Malgaigne's injury;
Epidemiology
-
One of the most common musculoskeletal injuries in children age 4 and under
-
Uncommon in children over 5 yrs of age secondary to the distal attachments of the orbicular ligament are sufficiently strong to prevent its proximal migration
-
Peak incidence is from age of 1–3 yrs old
Risk Factors
-
Frequently, the traction force occurs when the child suddenly attempts to pull away from a parent or drops to the ground.
-
The necessary force also can occur while a child is being pulled by the hand or forearm, such as in pulling a child as he or she stumbles, lifting him or her up by the hand, or swinging the child by the hand.
Diagnosis
-
Postreduction views not usually indicated
-
Postreduction views may be indicated if the child's arm does not return to normal function after reduction attempts are made.
-
Consider additional imaging of the forearm, wrist, or humerus in young children.
History
-
In more than 80% of cases, there is a history of sudden longitudinal traction to a pronated, extended forearm.
-
May be a history of a “click” felt or heard by the person who pulled the child's arm
-
May be a history of an incidental fall in which the arm, elbow, and forearm were impacted between the ground and the child's trunk
-
Immediately following the injury, the child is usually tearful due to the pain and refuses to use the affected arm.
-
Pain, if vocalized, may be referred toward the wrist.
-
The child holds the forearm by his or her side, always in a pronated and partially flexed position (nursemaid's position).
-
Occasionally, there is no history of trauma and the parents may notice the affected extremity not being used.
Physical Exam
-
Child refuses to use the affected limb.
-
The forearm is always pronated and the elbow is partially flexed.
-
The child typically holds the affected limb by his or her side, sometimes supporting the forearm with the other hand.
-
The child may be tearful during physical exam.
-
The child also may appear content and playful, but declines to move the affected arm.
-
Gentle palpation can reveal local tenderness over the anterolateral aspect of the radial head.
-
By carefully avoiding movements involving the elbow and forearm, one can note painless range of motion of the wrist, hand, and shoulder.
-
Typically no obvious swelling or deformity
-
There is minimal restriction to flexion and extension of the elbow, but supination of the forearm is markedly limited and resisted.
-
Often, the appearance is that of a wrist injury with the wrist flexed and pronated.
-
It is imperative to examine the joints above and below the suspected injury to increase the likelihood of identifying the primary injury site.
Diagnostic Tests & Interpretation
Diagnosis is based on history alone.
Consider prereduction radiographs if there is a history of trauma.
P.409
Differential Diagnosis
-
Posterior elbow dislocation
-
Distal radial buckle fracture (torus) or other radial fracture
-
Septic elbow
-
Ulnar fracture
-
Supracondylar fracture or other fracture of the humerus
-
Avulsion of the medial or lateral epicondyle
Treatment
-
Analgesia:
-
Not typically necessary for reduction
-
Consider acetaminophen (15 mg/kg) or ibuprofen (5–10 mg/kg) as needed.
-
-
Reduction techniques:
-
The thumb is placed in the region of the radial head for palpation and the exertion of mild pressure (anterior to posterior).
-
The child's forearm is gently but firmly rotated into full supination.
-
The elbow is then flexed to 90 degrees by holding the child's forearm above the wrist and stabilizing the humerus and elbow with the other hand to prevent rotation of the shoulder. If any resistance is met, one should continue flexing the elbow to the point of maximal flexion.
-
As reduction is achieved, a palpable and sometimes audible “click” can be felt in the region of the radial head.
-
This maneuver will typically achieve instantaneous reduction of the radial head and sometimes instant relief of pain.
-
Consider a hyperpronation maneuver if supination/flexion fails.
-
-
Postreduction evaluation:
-
The child should typically be observed for 15 min for a return of full function and use of the affected arm.
-
If function has not normalized in 15 min, a repeated attempt at reduction is recommended.
-
In some studies, the delay until normal use of the arm is achieved is longer when there has been a delay in treatment from the time of injury.
-
If there is no evidence of recovery after several reduction attempts, the diagnosis must be reconsidered.
-
-
Immobilization:
-
Immobilization is not necessary for the 1st occurrence of subluxation.
-
If reduction is delayed for more than 12 hr following injury, an attempt is made to support the limb with a sling for 10 days with the elbow in 90 degrees of flexion and the forearm in full supination, but most toddlers discard the sling within minutes.
-
For cases of multiple recurrences of nursemaid's elbow, some clinicians recommend a trial of immobilization of the upper limb in an above-elbow cast for 2–3 wks after evaluation by a pediatric orthopedist.
-
Additional Treatment
Additional Therapies
-
Special considerations:
-
In a child under 6 mos of age, consider abuse from a caretaker while evaluating the child. However, subluxation can occur while simply rolling over in this age group.
-
Recurrence of subluxation as a result of subsequent pulls occurs in ∼5–40% of cases.
-
-
Rehabilitation:
-
Prevention is key. The parent should be advised to avoid longitudinal traction strains on the arm by not pulling on the hand or wrist, but rather pick the child up by the trunk.
-
For the child who recovers fully after 1 or 2 reduction maneuvers, further therapy or intervention is unnecessary.
-
Surgery/Other Procedures
-
Very rarely, the subluxed radial head may be irreducible by manipulation, especially in recurrent cases, requiring surgical intervention.
-
The need for open reduction is extremely rare.
Ongoing Care
Follow-Up Recommendations
-
Even when multiple attempts at closed reduction fail, spontaneous reduction almost always occurs.
-
Usually no long-term sequelae
-
Consider an occult fracture or cartilaginous injury if the response to treatment is not typical.
Additional Reading
Bachman D, Santora S. Textbook of pediatric emergency medicine. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins, 1993.
Christoph RA. Emergency medicine, a comprehensive study guide. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1996.
Rand FF. Emergency medicine. Boston: Little, Brown, 1992.
Schunk JE. Radial head subluxation: epidemiology and treatment of 87 episodes. Ann Emerg Med. 1990;19:1019–1023.
Tachdjian MO, ed. Pediatric orthopedics. Philadelphia: WB Saunders, 1990.
Codes
ICD9
832.2 Nursemaid's elbow
Clinical Pearls
-
Possibility of recurrence can be minimized by avoidance of pulling on the child's hand or arm.
-
Long-term sequelae unlikely