NONUNIONS AND MALUNIONS OF THE FEMORAL SHAFT AND PATELLA

Ovid: Chapman’s Orthopaedic Surgery

Editors: Chapman, Michael W.
Title: Chapman’s Orthopaedic Surgery, 3rd Edition
> Table of Contents > SECTION
II – FRACTURES, DISLOCATIONS, NONUNIONS, AND MALUNIONS > Malunions
and Nonunions > CHAPTER 30 – NONUNIONS AND MALUNIONS OF THE FEMORAL
SHAFT AND PATELLA

CHAPTER 30
NONUNIONS AND MALUNIONS OF THE FEMORAL SHAFT AND PATELLA
Michael W. Chapman
M. W. Chapman: Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of California, Davis, Sacramento, California, 95817.
NONUNIONS OF THE FEMUR
Nonunions of the femur are rare, except in the femoral
neck. Both nonoperative and operative treatment methods have high rates
of union because of the excellent blood supply to the femur. The most
common cause of nonunion (other than in the femoral neck) is an open
fracture complicated by infection (15). The etiology of nonunion and the preferred methods of treatment for each section of the femur are quite variable.
MIDSHAFT
This discussion focuses on nonunions of the midshaft
from more than 2.5 cm distal to the lesser trochanter, to within 10 cm
of the knee joint. Supracondylar nonunions are discussed in the next
section of this chapter. See Chapter 29 for nonunions about the hip.
Because of the development and subsequent popularity of
locked intramedullary nailing using closed techniques, nonunions of the
femoral shaft are unusual (46). The literature
up to 1979 reported an incidence of nonunion of 2.1% in open nailing of
the femur and 0.2% in closed nailing of the femur (11).
Today, the incidence in closed fractures remains less than 1%. Nonunion
is more likely to occur when an open fracture is complicated by
infection or when there is loss of bone substance. External fixation

P.952



is usually indicated for infected nonunions (3). Infected nonunions are discussed in detail in Chapter 133 and Chapter 135.
The incidence of nonunion is higher in nonoperative treatment of shaft
fractures than with intramedullary nailing. Nonunion is most likely to
be a complication of failure of plate fixation of the femur. Nonunions
of fractures treated nonoperatively are usually accompanied by
shortening, malrotation, and significant angulation. Nonunions
accompanying intramedullary fixation are usually in good alignment, but
a broken nail may be present. Nonunions with plate fixation are usually
accompanied by failure of fixation. Good cortical contact is usually
present, but angulation may be a problem.

Delayed union or nonunion after intramedullary nailing
can be treated, if the medullary canal is in reasonable alignment, by
removal of the original nail and closed reamed intramedullary renailing
(27). An open procedure is necessary when
alignment of the medullary canal is poor or there is hardware in place
that requires removal. With closed intramedullary nailing, bone
grafting is usually unnecessary (30). In open procedures, however, onlay cancellous bone grafting should be done routinely (21,36,37).
Intramedullary nailing is the preferred method of fixation, except
where distortion of the intramedullary canal makes nailing impossible (13).
In such cases, plate fixation is indicated, and the principles
described for plate fixation of supracondylar nonunions apply (35).
Nonunions with defects or severe shortening may need specialized
techniques such as allograft replacement, free microvascularized bone
grafts (45), newer bone inductive methods (23,24), or Ilizarov techniques (see Chapter 32).
Closed Intramedullary Nailing without Bone Grafting
For closed intramedullary nailing of a nonunion of the
shaft of the femur without bone grafting, follow the basic principles
of closed intramedullary nailing described in Chapter 11, Chapter 19, and Chapter 20.
  • Place the patient in a lateral decubitus
    position on a fracture table or on a radiolucent regular table, with
    the femur to be operated on uppermost. The supine position on a
    fracture table can be used as well.
  • Expose the trochanteric region through a gluteus maximus–splitting incision.
  • If an intramedullary nail is present,
    remove it. If it is a cannulated design, first place a 3.5 mm reaming
    guide pin. If the nail is broken, it is usually possible to remove it
    by closed technique. First, remove the broken proximal piece of the
    nail. Ream the proximal fragment until it is larger than the diameter
    of the remaining distal portion of the nail. In most nonunions in
    average-size patients, I use a 15 mm or larger nail. In large patients,
    I advise a 16 or 17 mm nail. Thus, it is possible to ream up to 15 to
    17 mm.
  • The distal fragment of the nail can then
    be removed by one of several techniques. It may be possible, under
    fluoroscopic control, to grasp its proximal end with a strong
    bronchoscopy forceps and pull it out. A set of specialized instruments
    for removal of nails and nail fragments designed by Dr. Robert Winquist
    is now available from Snap-On MPD (Kenosha, WI). In this set, one of
    the most useful devices I have found for removal of nails is a series
    of guidepins in various sizes with bullet tips, together with
    associated guidepins with no bullet. To remove a cannulated broken
    nail, insert (under fluoroscopy) the largest ball tip that will fit
    through the end of the nail and locate the ball just outside the tip of
    the nail. Then jam this guidepin by driving a non-ball-tip guidepin
    beside it. Attach the Jacobs chuck T-wrench with flanges to the ball
    tip guidepin and using a mallet, extract the broken segment. “Easy
    outs” and other special tools for broken nail removal are also
    available. If it is impossible to remove the distal section of the nail
    by one of these techniques, or if the nail is solid, make a small
    window in the bone distally and tap it out, or open the nonunion site
    to extract the remaining portion of the nail.
  • Once the canal is clear, carry out closed nailing by the usual technique (see Chapter 11, Chapter 19, and Chapter 20).
    Use a nail at least 2 mm wider than the previous nail, if possible.
    Ream sufficiently to obtain good cortical contact on both sides of the
    nonunion, and use a nail that extends distally to within 1 cm of the
    subchondral bone of the knee. I always use statically locked
    interlocking nails. I prefer the Alta nail (Howmedica, Rutherford, NJ)
    because its slap-hammer driver facilitates compression of the fracture.
    In the vast majority of cases, I lock the nail distally first, impact
    the fracture by reversing the slap-hammer or by applying an AO
    distractor in compression, and then lock proximally (Fig. 30.1, Fig. 30.2, Fig. 30.3).
    Figure 30.1. A:Radiograph
    of a nonunion of the midshaft of the femur in a 47-year-old man who
    sustained the fracture 29 years earlier. Treatment was complicated by
    infection. Thirty previous operations had been performed. At this
    point, the limb was 1 inch short, the patient had had no recurrence of
    infection for 5 years, and he had a painful deformity of the femur. B:
    Closed intramedullary nailing using a 17-mm-diameter nail was
    performed. This AP radiograph shows early union 12 weeks after the
    procedure. The patient was treated before locking nails were available.
    Today, the fracture site would have been fixed in compression with a
    statically locked nail.
    Figure 30.2. A:
    AP radiograph of a subtrochanteric nonunion after blade plate fixation
    of a comminuted subtrochanteric fracture with failure of the plate. B: AP radiograph showing treatment with an Alta rod connector combined with a hip screw and an autologous bone graft.
    Figure 30.3. A:
    AP radiograph of a 45-year-old man 1 year after ipsilateral concomitant
    fracture of the femoral neck and shaft treated with an Alta rod
    connector. There was union of the femoral neck and nonunion of the
    shaft fracture. B: The nonunion was
    treated by removal of the rod connector and repeat closed nailing with
    a larger nail with static locking in compression. This AP radiograph
    shows union 9 months after repeat nailing.
Unless pathologic bone or infection is present, the
union rate after repeat reamed closed nailing of femoral nonunions is
reported to be 53% to 78% after a single procedure and 87% to 95% after
a second procedure (16,19,43).
In my personal experience of 41 nonunions of the femoral shaft treated
by this technique between 1983 and 1999, the union rate was 78% after
one procedure and 95% after two procedures (16).
For proximal shaft and subtrochanteric nonunions,
reconstruction nails that provide fixation into the femoral head are
usually necessary (2,47) (Fig. 30.2).
Open Intramedullary Nailing and Bone Grafting
  • If an open technique is indicated, place
    the patient in the lateral decubitus position on either a regular
    operating table or on a fracture table, depending on your preference
    and the technique to be used. Use a direct lateral

    P.953



    approach to dissect posteriorly to the vastus lateralis and expose the femur by subperiosteal dissection (see Chapter 3). Preserve the medial and posterior soft-tissue attachments.

  • If plates and screws are present, remove
    them. If an intramedullary nail is present, remove it as described
    previously. If the nail is broken, it is possible to remove it directly
    through the nonunion site rather than through the buttock incision.
    Special techniques are not usually required.
    In most cases, it is necessary to take down the
    nonunion, open the medullary canal, and freshen the ends of the
    fracture. Reduce the fracture and carry out locked intramedullary
    nailing. With an osteotome, petal the femur for 5 cm proximal and
    distal to the nonunion site and place copious cancellous bone graft
    around the nonunion site. Close in the usual fashion over a drain.
In most cases of exchanged reamed nailing for nonunions,
the nonunion site is in compression and the femur is statically locked
postoperatively. This provides solid fixation, which permits early
weight bearing and a full rehabilitation program to work on joint range
of motion and muscle strengthening. For the first 6 weeks after repair,
it is advisable to ask the patient to use assistive devices, but I
usually allow them to progress to full weight bearing as tolerated.
Thereafter, patients can usually progress to full weight bearing but
must avoid activities other than ordinary walking and nonimpact
activities such as swimming and stationary bicycling until healing of
the nonunion occurs, as heralded by bridging callus or disappearance of
the nonunion site seen on two views.
Dynamization for Delayed Unions or Nonunions
Prior to the advent of interlocking nails, we treated
nonunions with exchanged reamed nailing using first-generation
nonlocking nails such as the Küntscher nail (7).
This resulted in union rates of 90% or better. The principle with this
technique was to allow full weight bearing on a nail, which would allow
compression of the fracture site. The same philosophy applies to
removing the cross screws from a locked screw to “dynamize” the
fracture, allowing weight bearing to cause compression and pulsatile
stimulus at the fracture site to promote union. This technique does
work and is most effective when the fracture pattern is such that with
impaction it becomes rotationally stable, such as in oblique nonunions.
In many nonunions, however, the configuration is such that either
excessive shortening will occur or rotational stability may ensue. I
have also found that the dynamization worsens some patients’ pain and
is not well tolerated. Currently, I dynamize only when there is no
comminution in the fracture site and an oblique pattern is present that
will stabilize with weight bearing. It is necessary to remove the cross
screws from only one end of the rod, and these should be at the end
farthest from the fracture site. This applies only to delayed union or
nonunions in the mid diaphysis. In all other fractures with delayed
union or nonunion, a much higher success rate will be achieved with
exchanged reamed locked nailing with compression across the fracture
site.
SUPRACONDYLAR AREA
Supracondylar nonunions may be entirely extra-articular or may have an intra-articular component. With interlocking

P.954



P.955



nails, it is possible to treat any nonunion that is sufficiently
proximal to the knee joint (a distal segment of 10 cm is required) by
placing two distal cross-locking screws. Modification of the nail by
cutting off part of its tip to allow it to be placed more distally may
permit the treatment of more distal nonunions, but this is a
specialized technique. Custom nails can be ordered as well.

Recently, retrograde intramedullary nails inserted
through the intracondylar notch of the femur—these nails are specially
designed for this purpose—have been advocated for the treatment of
supracondylar nonunions. Experience with these nails, however, has not
proven successful (P. Tornetta III, personal communication 1999). The
nails apparently do not provide sufficient purchase in the distal
fragment because of disuse osteoporosis secondary to the nonunion. At
present, I do not advise the use of retrograde supracondylar nails for
supracondylar nonunions.
Most supracondylar nonunions require bone grafting and
internal fixation using a variety of plates. Double-plate fixation
comparable to that described for the trochanteric region may be
indicated (see Chapter 29). Osteoporosis may
make solid screw fixation difficult to achieve. In elderly patients, in
cancellous bone, methacrylate can be inserted into the screw holes to
improve screw fixation. Cement is not advisable in younger patients
because if the appliance must be removed, considerable bone destruction
may be necessary to remove it. Consequently, methacrylate is used only
as a last resort. Back-up washers and nuts on the screws on the
opposite cortex are often helpful. Another useful technique is to take
a cortical or corticocancellous bone graft from the tibia or ilium, or
a femoral allograft, place it opposite the plate, and fix the screws
into this stronger bone. I believe this is more useful than dual-onlay
grafts. See the section on PERIPROSTHETIC FRACTURES in Chapter 20 for a discussion of this technique.
Sometimes, severe osteoporosis, severe comminution of
the distal femur, or destruction of the knee joint makes salvage of
knee joint motion impractical and internal fixation of the nonunion
extremely difficult. In such situations, consider immediate fusion of
the knee in combination with treatment of the nonunion. This can be
accomplished by double-plate fixation, or with a long intramedullary
nail traversing the femur and knee joint into the proximal tibia (4,30). In the series by Beall et al. (4),
fusion of the knee was not attempted, and after nail removal
preoperative range of motion of the knee was maintained or increased in
all cases.
In elderly patients with osteopenic bone and coexisting
arthritis of the knee, the morbidity of and low success rate with
internal fixation may not justify fixation. Total knee replacement with
a modular distal femoral component in some with acute fractures and in
difficult nonunions may be a better choice (18). Freedman et al. (18)
used the Kinematic rotating hinge knee (Howmedica, Rutherford, NJ cin
five patients with difficult distal femoral reconstructive problems
after fracture of the femur, and four were restored to ambulatory
status with good results on the Enneking rating system. One patient
required amputation as a result of deep infection.
Plate Fixation and Bone Grafting
  • If plate fixation and bone grafting are
    necessary, use the basic techniques for fixation of the shaft or
    supracondylar fractures of the femur (see Chapter 20 and Chapter 21). Place the patient in a supine position on a radiolucent operating table with a C-arm fluoroscope available.
  • Use an anterolateral exposure (10)
    because visualization of the condyles of the femur and knee joint is
    often necessary. Try not to strip the medial and posterior surfaces. I
    have never found release of the patellar tendon to be necessary.
  • Remove any hardware and correct any
    secondary deformity. A fibrous union in good position can be internally
    fixed in position; otherwise, take down the nonunion, freshen the bone
    ends, open the medullary canal, and refashion the bone ends to correct
    any deformity and maximize bone contact. Fixation choices include the
    AO 95° condylar blade plate, a dynamic compression screw and side
    plate, or the Alta distal condylar plate or 95° screw or bolt and side
    plate. I no longer use the AO condylar plate because it is difficult to
    use and not as versatile as the newer devices. (See Fig. 30.4, Fig. 30.5). Chapter 21 describes the full operative technique.
    Figure 30.4. A:
    AP radiograph of a 24-year-old woman 18 months after a T-type
    supracondylar fracture of the femur treated with an AO T plate. She has
    a painful nonunion with shortening and a varus deformity. B: AP radiograph of treatment with an Alta distal 95° condylar plate and screw combined with autologous bone graft.
    Figure 30.5. Supracondylar femoral nonunion. A: AP radiograph of the femur in a 35-year-old man who sustained a grade 3A open comminuted supracondylar fracture. B:
    After irrigation, debridement, and plate fixation, the fracture became
    infected and went on to a nonunion. This AP radiograph shows the
    original internal fixation with antibiotic beads in place. C,D:
    The plate and screws were removed and after resolution of the
    infection, the original treating physician internally fixed the
    fracture with a retrograde supracondylar nail. Unfortunately, this
    failed as well, resulting in a persistent nonunion. E,F:
    I first encountered the patient 18 months after the original fracture.
    There had been no evidence of infection for 15 months. I removed the
    nail and screws, and through an anterolateral approach applied an Alta
    lateral plate assembly. I augmented this with a smaller anterior plate
    and applied an iliac crest bone graft. The nonunion healed in 16 weeks
    with no recurrence of infection. Knee motion was from full extension to
    110° of flexion.
  • If necessary, add a second anterior 3.5
    or 4.5 mm narrow or reconstruction plate with six holes to place three
    bicortical screws in each fragment. Make this plate shorter than the
    side plate proximally. Obtain interfragmentary lag screw compression if
    possible.
  • Petal the bone about the fracture site, apply an onlay cancellous bone graft, and close over suction drainage.
Other specialized plating techniques include the “wave” plate (14,38) and an intramedullary plate (31). Cove et al. (14)
advise wave plating when treating nonunions where there is a segmental
defect more than 5 cm in length, where there has been a history of
sepsis, or where the medullary canal is unsuitable for intramedullary
nailing. Wave plating involves molding the plate into a wave
configuration so that it stands out from the femur throughout the zone
of bone deficiency and nonunion. This permits the placement of a large
volume of bone graft, which promotes union, makes for a structurally
stronger union when it occurs, and permits the use of a free
microvascularized fibular transfer. Using the wave plate method, Ring
et al. (38) achieved union in 41 of 42
consecutive complex ununited fractures of the femoral shaft at an
average of 6 months after fracture. Three required a

P.956



second bone graft, and two had recurrence of infection; in one of these there was a persistent nonunion. Matelic et al. (31)
have promoted the use of an AO dynamic compression plate placed in an
intramedullary location to serve as a medial buttress in fresh
fractures and nonunions where there is medial bone deficiency. The
advantages of the intramedullary location are that less soft-tissue
stripping (and thus devascularization) of the bone is necessary; more
surface area at the fracture site is available for bone grafting; and
the screw fixation from the accompanying lateral plate can be inserted
through the intramedullary plate, increasing the strength of fixation
and buttressing the medial cortex. The primary disadvantage of
endosteal plating is that it is technically demanding, resulting in
long surgery times and increased blood loss. In seven patients with
complex nonunions of the distal femur, Cove et al. (14) achieved union in all with an average time to union of 19 weeks (Fig. 30.6).

Figure 30.6. Wave plate: A: A 27-year-old man presented with an infected nonunion of 13 months duration. B:
Debridement was performed with application of an external fixator,
using a latissimus free flap to cover the defect at a subsequent
debridement 2 weeks later. C: Three weeks
after soft-tissue coverage, the patient underwent stabilization using a
16-hole broad dynamic compression plate with wave configuration
augmented with iliac crest bone graft. D:
At 7 months, the fracture had consolidated, and the patient was fully
weight bearing without pain. (From Cove JA, Lhowe DW, Jupiter JB,
Siliski JM. The Management of Femoral Diaphyseal Nonunions. J Orthop Trauma 1997;11:513, with permission.)
Figure 30.7 shows an AO broad
plate used as a medial buttress, combined with a 95° angled blade. The
technique of using a medial endosteal buttress plate is as follows (31):
Figure 30.7.
Medial endosteal buttress plate. An AO broad plate is used as a medial
buttress, combined with a 95° angled blade plate. (From Matelic TM,
Monroe MT, Mast JW. The Use of Endosteal Substitution in the Treatment
of Recalcitrant Nonunions of the Femur: Report of Seven Cases. J Orthop Trauma 1996;10:1, with permission.)
  • Use an articulating tension device or a femoral distractor to distract the fracture.
  • Use a gouge and curet to make a trough in
    the distal metaphysis on the medial aspect to allow the intramedullary
    plate to be seated against the blade.
  • Insert the plate into the intramedullary
    canal in a retrograde fashion and then, using a curved impactor, drive
    it into the prepared trough to abut against the blade.
  • Then reduce the fracture by diminishing the distraction force and allowing the fracture surfaces to oppose.
  • Insert two or three screws into the lateral cortex only and impact them against the plate, pushing it medially.
  • Insert the other screws through the holes
    in both plates. To accomplish this, use a 3.2 mm drill to drill the
    lateral cortex with the appropriate drill guide. Then pass a 1.6 mm
    Kirschner wire (K-wire) through the hole and use it to feel the holes
    on the medullary plate. When you know the direction, direct the drill
    in the same path toward the medial cortex, and penetrate it. Insertion
    of these screws is frequently skewed so that the screws actually thread
    the hole in the plate as they pass into

    P.957



    P.958



    the medial cortex. This ensures the blocking action of the plate. In Figure 30.7, the fifth screw from the top would have this effect. The medial plate is thus locked between the blade and the screws.

Postoperatively, begin motion immediately to preserve
and improve knee range of motion. In most cases, continuous passive
motion can be started after drain removal and continued until the
patient can actively carry out range-of-motion exercises. Active
assistive exercises with a therapist are helpful. With good internal
fixation, external protection is usually unnecessary. Confirm the
presence of bone union with four-plane radiographs or anteroposterior
(AP) and lateral tomograms before beginning full weight bearing.
Infected Nonunions of the Femur
The treatment of infection is addressed in Chapter 132, Chapter 133, and Chapter 135.
A few comments about the treatment of infected nonunions are pertinent
here. The general principles in the treatment of infected femoral
diaphyseal nonunions are well outlined in the algorithm advocated by
Cove et al. (Fig. 30.8) (14). In treating infected nonunions,

P.959



the first step in the vast majority of cases is eradication or control
of the infection, followed by restoration of the soft-tissue envelope (23).
Generally, this requires a radical debridement of the nonunion site,
removing all scarred soft tissues that are impairing revascularization
and all necrotic bone. Take cultures to identify the infecting
organisms. In the femur, stabilization to maintain alignment and length
is essential. Although traction can be used, in most cases the period
of time that stabilization in the absence of internal fixation will be
necessary is such that external fixation is best. If the infection can
be resolved and there are particular advantages in converting from
external to internal fixation, such conversion may occur, but
definitive treatment to union in external fixation may be necessary.
Usually, several debridements are necessary and treatment with
intravenous antibiotics for up to 6 weeks, with suppressive oral
antibiotics for longer, may be necessary.

Figure 30.8.
Clinical algorithm for treating femoral nonunion. (From Cove JA, Lhowe
DW, Jupiter JB, Siliski JM. The Management of Femoral Diaphyseal
Nonunions. J Orthop Trauma 1997;11:570, with permission.)
The success of treatment of nonunion is greatly enhanced
by having a well-vascularized muscular envelope completely around the
fracture. This is usually not a great problem in the femur because of
the large muscle envelope of the thigh, but skin grafts, rotation
flaps, and free tissue transfer may be necessary to provide an
appropriate environment for definitive treatment of the nonunion (40). Ilizarov techniques may be appropriate for the particular fracture (see Chapter 32 for details).
Once the infection is eradicated or well controlled,
then iliac crest bone graft in external fixation usually suffices for
those nonunions without a major gap. Usually, conversion from external
fixation to intramedullary nailing is not appropriate because of the
high risk of infection, but conversion from the external fixator to
plates may be appropriate. In such cases, removal of the external
fixator to allow the pin tracks to heal prior to open plate fixation is
usually advisable. In the interim, stability and length can be
maintained with a cast-brace with intermittent traction if necessary.
For larger defects, iliac crest bone graft combined with a vascularized
fibula may be necessary (46).

P.960



Slätis and Paavolainen (41)
advocate one-stage treatment of infected nonunions of the femoral shaft
by excision of dead and infected tissue, resection of bone ends,
cancellous bone grafting, and external fixation. They were successful
in four of five cases. This small series, however, does not prove the
efficacy of this method, and I prefer the staged approach advocated by
Cove et al. (14) (Fig. 30.8).

In my own series of 21 supracondylar femoral shaft
nonunions treated between 1983 and 1997, using plating and bone graft,
I was able to achieve union in 95% (10). In most series, overall success rates for treatment of aseptic and septic nonunions of the femur are 70% to 97% (4,5,13,14,25,27,31,38,39,40 and 41).
MALUNIONS OF THE FEMUR
SHAFT
Malunions of the femoral shaft are not uncommon. In my
experience, they occur most often after treatment with cast-braces,
which is rare today, or after treatment of unstable and/or open
fractures with small intramedullary nails. Almost all malunions of the
shaft show combined deformities of malrotation, angulation, and
shortening. Shortening of more than 2.5 cm necessitates a cumbersome
shoe lift and causes considerable inconvenience to active patients. It
generally requires correction either by lengthening the shortened femur
or by shortening the contralateral femur (12).
Malrotation is better tolerated in external rotation than in internal
rotation. As long as there is at least 10° to 15° of rotation beyond
neutral in either external or internal rotation, patients rarely have
functional problems. When they cannot rotate to neutral, significant
functional problems usually require correction of the malrotation.
Inability to rotate the extremity at least to a neutral position places
the knee and ankle joints out of the plane of progression for walking.
This produces an inefficient and unsightly gait and interferes with
sports activities.
Minimal to moderate angulation is better tolerated than
significant malrotation or shortening. There are three indications for
correction of angulation: poor function, often accompanied by pain;
poor cosmesis; and the potential for late degenerative arthritis due to
abnormal stresses across the knee joint (26).
Decisions to undertake surgical correction for the first two complaints
depend not so much on the degree of angulation present as on the
patient’s complaints. Generally speaking, angulation of less than 10°
rarely produces significant functional or cosmetic impairment.
Angulation of more than 20° almost always creates problems for the
patient. The effect of angulation on joint function and possible late
degenerative arthritis is more difficult to judge. In most patients,
angulation of less than 10°, particularly in the middle third of the
shaft, rarely creates problems. The preexisting alignment of the
patient’s legs, however, has a major effect; for example, a patient
with preexisting genu varum may not tolerate an additional 10° of varus
angulation and may require surgical correction. Generally, angulation
of more than 15° requires correction in active patients. These are
multifactorial decisions that require close consultation with the
patient. The goal of restoration of the mechanical axis of the
extremity is discussed in Chapter 26 and Chapter 32.
The type of surgical procedure indicated for correction
of malunion of the femur depends on the degree of deformity, the
alignment of the medullary canal, and the location of the deformity.
From a technical viewpoint, open procedures are the easiest to perform,
but many deformities of the femur are correctable by closed
intramedullary osteotomy and nailing techniques. Ilizarov techniques
have added a whole new dimension to the treatment of malunions (see Chapter 32).
Malunions in recently united fractures have soft callus.
In most cases, it is best to expose the fracture site, take down the
malunion, and restore the normal anatomy of the femur. Late malunions
with significant remodeling are difficult to take down through the
original fracture site, and various osteotomies are applicable.
Closed Intramedullary Osteotomy
Closed intramedullary osteotomy is a specialized
technique that requires significant experience with closed
intramedullary nailing (9,17,44).
For this technique, the offset in the diameter of the medullary canal
must be less than 25%. Alignment must be good enough to allow the
passage of intramedullary instruments and a nail down the medullary
canal of the femur past the deformity. The technique is best suited for
correction of shortening of less than 5.0 cm and for correction of
malrotation. In some cases, angulation is correctable as well, but
often an open osteotomy to realign the femoral canal is necessary. In
malunions of the middle third of the shaft, internal fixation with
medullary nails rather than plates and screws is preferred because
failure is less likely and immediate weight bearing is possible in most
cases.
  • Place the patient in the lateral decubitus position on a fracture table with the extremity to be operated on uppermost (see Chapter 11 and Chapter 20).
    Prepare and drape from buttocks to the tibial traction pin. Through a
    gluteus-splitting incision, expose the piriformis fossa of the femur.
  • If an intramedullary nail is already in
    place, the procedure is greatly simplified; remove the nail and insert
    a reaming guide pin. If a nail is not present, it is necessary to
    reestablish the patency of the medullary canal. In some cases, a 3.5 mm
    guide pin can be passed directly down the canal, and reaming can
    proceed. In other

    P.961


    cases,
    the medullary canal at the fracture site is blocked by callus and must
    be reopened. To achieve this, a set of recently sharpened, heavy,
    flagged Küntscher guide pins or hand reamers must be available. If
    angular deformity is present, one of the guidepins will need a bent tip.

  • First, place a reaming guide pin down to
    the blockage and progressively ream the canal to the size required for
    the nail to be inserted. For these osteotomies, larger-than-normal
    nails are used; in the average-size man, I use at least a 16 mm nail.
    Enlarging the proximal canal allows better working room for the guides
    necessary to perforate the blockage.
  • Insert a sharp-tipped guide pin of the
    appropriate curvature and drive it with a mallet into the bone blocking
    the canal. Take care to remain in the central axis of the canal. If a
    straight-tipped pin is used, this can be attached to a power source and
    the blockage drilled. If the bone is soft, direct penetration may be
    possible. Otherwise, it will be necessary to withdraw the sharp-tipped
    guide pin after penetrating 1 cm or so. Reinsert the reaming guide pin,
    and with the end-cutting reamer open the canal in the perforated
    portion. Alternate these two methods until the blockage is opened. If
    the blockage is in the proximal half of the femur, the hand reamers
    from the AO instrumentation are useful as well. This technique can be
    difficult and time consuming.
  • Rather than spending inordinate amounts
    of time trying to open the canal by closed technique, I often open the
    malunion site and perform an open osteotomy. Once the canal is open,
    insert the reaming guide pin distally to the subchondral bone at the
    knee, and progressively ream the canal to the desired diameter.
  • With closed technique, insert the Pearson intramedullary saw (Fig. 30.9)
    and transect the femur at the appropriate level. In preoperative
    planning, it is important to select an osteotomy site slightly proximal
    or distal to the fracture site in normal bone. Closed osteotomies at
    the old fracture site give the most precise correction, but an
    incomplete cut due to asymmetry of the canal will require osteoclasis,
    or percutaneous insertion of a 0.25-inch osteotome from the lateral
    side of the thigh, to complete the osteotomy.
    Figure 30.9.
    Intramedullary saw for osteotomy of the femur using the closed
    intramedullary technique. The cutting blade at the distal end works on
    the principle of a cam and is available in diameters of 12 to 17 mm.
    (Courtesy of Biomet, Bourbon, IL.) B: Saw with parts labeled. (From Winquist RA, Hansen ST Jr, Pearson RE. Closed Intramedullary Shortening of the Femur. Clin Orthop 1978;136:54, with permission.)
  • When straightening an angular deformity,
    drive the nail into the central portion of the distal femoral condyles.
    This will correct any angular deformity.
  • If malrotation is present, place two
    Steinmann pins or Schanz screws, one above and one below the osteotomy,
    for rotational control before performing the osteotomy. Place these
    pins directly lateral, with one in the proximal fragment and one in the
    distal fragment, through only the lateral cortex of the femur. Do not
    penetrate the medullary canal proximally or the pin will interfere with
    the saw. Place the pins in alignment with each other initially, and
    then measure the angulation between the pins after correction of the
    deformity. Before surgery, make a template by bending a K-wire or
    cutting a piece of sheet aluminum to measure the rotational angle. A
    commercially available goniometer can be used instead, but this is more
    difficult to read.
  • Maintaining rotational correction during
    the drive of the medullary nail can be difficult. For this reason, I
    prefer to use the Chick-Langren table (Kirshner Medical, Greenwood,
    SC), where the extremity is controlled by a large, threaded Steinmann
    pin through the proximal tibia or distal femur attached to the traction
    apparatus of the table. This gives nearly absolute control during the
    nailing.
  • P.962


  • Then drive an interlocking nail, which
    can be statically locked. If the limb is less than 2.5 cm short, this
    discrepancy can usually be corrected at the same time by distraction
    and closed intramedullary bone grafting (Fig. 30.10) (8).
    Although length can be gained through the traction apparatus of the
    fracture table, it is more effective, and safer, to use an AO femoral
    distractor. Attach the two Schanz pins inserted as guides for
    correction of rotation to the femoral distractor. Distract slowly over
    15–20 minutes. To avoid excessive traction on the sciatic nerve, do no
    soft-tissue releases and keep the knee flexed to 90° during the
    lengthening. Although I have had no difficulty with the sciatic nerve
    with acute lengthenings of less than 2.5 cm, it is advisable to use
    sensory-evoked potentials to monitor function in the sciatic nerve
    during lengthening. Johnson has performed acute lengthenings of 0.4–3.3
    cm using an open technique with various bone grafting materials and has
    achieved healing in 18 of 19 patients (22,23).
    Figure 30.10. Closed intramedullary bone grafting and nailing. A: Insert a guide pin. B: Ream the proximal femur. Do not ream in the gap if it is necessary to ream distally. Save the reamings. C: Pass the guide pin into the distal fragment. Insert a large chest tube down to the fracture. D:
    Push reamings and finely morcelized graft down the chest tube by hand,
    using the flexible shaft from the AO medullary reamers. Overfill the
    defect site. E: Insert an intramedullary
    nail, which is statically interlocked. (From Chapman MW. Closed
    Intramedullary Bone Grafting and Nailing of Segmental Defects of the
    Femur. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1980;62:1004, with permission.)
  • When lengthening is anticipated, save all
    medullary reamings and bone marrow. For lengthenings of less than 2.5
    cm, this will provide enough grafting material to fill the defect. If
    insufficient graft is available, harvest cancellous bone from the
    inside of the greater trochanter through the entry site for the nail.
    If more is needed, obtain cancellous bone from the posterior ilium.
    Morcelize this bone finely with a bone-cutting forceps or bone mill.
  • With the reaming guide pin in place,
    insert a large plastic chest tube down the medullary canal into the
    defect site. Cut the chest tube to allow about 4 inches to protrude
    from the top of the femur. Hold the chest tube in place with a Kocher
    clamp on the top of the tube. It is possible to place the chest tube by
    fluoroscopy using the radiographic marker in the chest tube. Insert the
    morcelized bone graft into the chest tube; do not place too much at one
    time because it may jam in the tube. Place the smaller, flexible AO
    reamer shaft, without the reaming head, over the guide pin and use it
    to push the graft into the defect site. Completely fill the defect site
    with cancellous bone and reaming materials. This is a meticulous and
    time-consuming technique. Overfill the defect site with graft. After
    inserting the bone graft, ensure that length has been maintained, then
    insert and statically lock an intramedullary nail.
I have used this technique in 15 patients. Union
occurred in all 15, and no refractures occurred after removal of the
nail. Substantial remodeling is necessary to achieve adequate strength,
so I advise leaving the nail in for no less than 24 months. In the two
cases for which lengthening of 4 cm or more was performed, supplemental
open cancellous bone grafting was later necessary due to inadequate
bone stock at the defect site (union had occurred, however).
This technique is also useful in selected defects in the
femur caused by open fractures with bone loss. In the latter case,
irrigate and debride the wound, initially leave it open, and
subsequently close it. Maintain the length of the femur by skeletal
traction. At 21 days, when the wound has healed satisfactorily and
there is no evidence of infection, perform closed intramedullary bone
grafting.
Closed Intramedullary Shortening of the Contralateral Femur
A separate lengthening procedure with an external
fixator is usually necessary when the discrepancy is more than 2.5–3.0
cm. In these cases, an alternative technique to equalize leg lengths is
to shorten the contralateral femur using a closed intramedullary
technique. Shortening the

P.963


contralateral
femur is technically much easier and safer than lengthening. Although
originally described by Küntscher, this method was popularized by
Winquist et al. (44) (Fig. 30.9, Fig. 30.11).
Although the technique shortens the patient’s overall stature, and in
large corrections will affect overall body proportions, it is
technically a much simpler technique than lengthening, and it offers
the advantages of immediate weight bearing, early union, and early
return to function (Fig. 30.12).

Figure 30.11. Closed intramedullary shortening of the femur. A: Ream the medullary canal to the appropriate size—usually 15–16 mm in the average-size male. Remove the reaming guide pin. B: Make the distal saw cut first, in the middle of the isthmus of the femur. C: Make the second saw cut proximally at the appropriate distance from the distal cut. D:
Insert the back-cutting chisel and split the intercalary fragment along
the linea aspera. Manipulate the fragments outside the gap with the
chisel, or push them out of the way with a small Küntscher nail. E:
Insert the intramedullary nail over a driving guide pin and shorten the
femur as the nail is driven. (Redrawn from Winquist RA, Hansen ST Jr,
Pearson RE. Closed Intramedullary Shortening of the Femur. Clin Orthop 1978;136:54, with permission.)
Figure 30.12. A: Preoperative AP radiograph showing the planned osteotomy sites to equalize a leg-length discrepancy of 25 mm. B: Postoperative AP radiograph showing correction of the leg-length discrepancy with a locked Alta nail for fixation.
Preoperative Planning
Preoperative planning is extremely important.
Determination of the actual leg-length discrepancy can be difficult. I
have not found scanograms to be consistently reliable, so I use them
only for confirmation of other measurements. The best technique is to
place blocks under the short leg of the standing patient to level the
pelvis. Rely on your judgment of the correction of the discrepancy and
the patient’s feelings about the correction. Try to obtain a level
pelvis and take into account any distortion of the pelvis that may be
present from old trauma or developmental or congenital abnormalities.
Then confirm the clinical measurement by taking an AP radiograph of the
pelvis with the patient again standing on enough blocks to correct the
leg-length discrepancy. Use either the film or a horizontal marker to
establish a level plane of reference. Take full-length AP and lateral
radiographs of the femur to be shortened to ensure that there is no
abnormality that would contraindicate shortening.
If bilateral femoral trauma has occurred and shortening
is to be performed on a previously fractured femur, the osteotomy must
be performed in an area of normal bone, preferably proximal to the
fracture site. Using the preoperative radiographs, plan the site of the
osteotomies and measure their distance from the tip of the trochanter,
taking into account x-ray magnification.
Intraoperative blood loss is usually less than 500 cc;
however, postoperative bleeding into the thigh can result in up to a
40% drop in the hemoglobin level. In young healthy patients,
transfusion is rarely required.
Technique
  • Place the patient in the lateral
    decubitus position on a fracture table with the extremity to be
    operated on uppermost, and expose the entry to the medullary canal in
    the usual fashion (see Chapter 11 and Chapter 20).
  • Insert a 3.5 mm reaming guide pin.
    Progressively ream the medullary canal to the desired size. In closed
    shortening, the saw is more likely to transect the femur if a larger
    saw is used and the canal is reamed widely. With a reamer of known
    diameter in the site of the proposed saw cut, visualize the femur on a
    lateral view. The size of the reamer provides a guide to the size of
    the saw needed to cut through the linea aspera. Take care in smaller
    patients not to overream the femur. Overthinning of the anterior cortex
    will result in comminution and inability to complete the osteotomy.
    Intraoperative monitoring of the reaming process by fluoroscopy avoids
    this problem. When reaming a closed intramedullary canal, make a 5 mm
    or larger drill hole in the distal metaphysis of the canal to
    decompress the canal to reduce the embolization of marrow contents.
    Proceed slowly with reaming and progress by 0.5 mm increments. Although
    it has been reported, I have never encountered fat embolism syndrome or
    adult respiratory distress syndrome after closed intramedullary
    osteotomy (Fig. 30.11A) (20).
  • Set the medullary saw for the most distal cut first. Insert

    P.964



    the saw and verify by fluoroscopy that it is in the appropriate
    position. Make the saw cut. Because of the teardrop cross-sectional
    shape of the femur, if the saw used is too small, the cut may be
    incomplete posteriorly. Either place a larger saw or complete the
    osteotomy, either by osteoclasis or by placing a 5 mm osteotome
    percutaneously from a lateral approach to cut the remaining bridge. In
    most cases, sufficient reaming can be done to allow a large-enough saw
    to make a complete cut (Fig. 30.11B).

  • Carefully set the measuring device on the
    saw for the second osteotomy, insert the saw, and verify correct
    position by fluoroscopy. The cam of the cutter is 15 mm long, providing
    a useful reference to verify the length between cuts. Make the second
    cut. An incomplete cut can make displacement of the intercalary
    fragment difficult. If only a small bridge of bone remains, insert a 12
    mm Küntscher nail down to the proximal osteotomy and abduct the
    proximal fragment. A firm blow to the tip of the fragment will often
    break it free. If this does not occur easily, then percutaneously
    insert a 5 mm osteotome from a lateral approach and transect the bone
    bridge. Occasionally, bone spikes are left on the main shaft fragments,
    which will prevent complete shortening; these can be removed by a
    percutaneous osteotome if necessary (Fig. 30.11C).
  • Next, split the intercalary fragment
    using the back-cutting osteotome supplied with the medullary saw. Under
    fluoroscopic control, insert the back-cutting osteotome and pull it
    firmly against the distal surface of the intercalary segment at the
    linea aspera. Hold it firmly in position and gently tap the handle of
    the saw with the slotted mallet to cut the intercalary fragment. A
    single cut usually splits the fragment into two halves (Fig. 30.11D).
  • Displace the intercalary fragments out of
    the osteotomy site. This can be done by pulling them to the side with
    the back-cutting osteotome, or they can be pushed out into the soft
    tissues with a small Küntscher nail inserted into the medullary canal.
    As long as one end of the intercalary fragments lies outside the
    femoral shaft, they will come to lie outside the osteotomy site and
    adjacent to the femoral shaft when shortening is performed. The
    preferred location for the intercalary fragments is medial, although
    generally one fragment ends up medial and the other lateral.
  • Insert a driving guide pin and drive an
    interlocking medullary nail into position; the nail should be 1 mm in
    diameter smaller than the canal was reamed. To accomplish shortening,
    it is easiest to drive the nail until it just exits the proximal
    fragment. Loosen the traction and manually shorten the femur to close
    the osteotomy and bring the tip of the nail just into the distal
    fragment. While manually holding the osteotomy closed and maintaining
    proper rotation, drive the nail into position. If distraction occurs
    during the drive, extract the nail until the osteotomy closes and then
    redrive it while holding the osteotomy closed. I always interlock both
    distally and proximally. Lock distally first, impact the osteotomy to
    close it and achieve compression, and then lock proximally (Fig. 30.11E).
  • Wash and debride the entry wound
    thoroughly to help prevent heterotopic bone formation. Close the wounds
    in layers. Do not use a drain.
Postoperative Care
After shortening, considerable hemorrhage into the thigh
can occur. Without blood replacement, I have seen a drop in the
hematocrit in some patients into the low 20s. Monitor the hemoglobin or
hematocrit

P.965


on
a daily basis until it stabilizes. Immediately apply a knee immobilizer
in the operating room, with good thigh coverage to compress the thigh;
this may help control hemorrhage. Because of the shortening, patients
lose some control of the quadriceps and hamstring muscles and will have
an unstable knee immediately after surgery. The knee immobilizer
controls the knee and allows immediate weight bearing. Start the
patient immediately on knee range-of-motion and thigh muscle
progressive resistance exercises. Patients can bear weight as tolerated
wearing the knee immobilizer and using crutches. With shortening of 2
inches or less, most patients gain sufficient quadriceps control that
the knee immobilizer can be abandoned after 6 weeks. Most patients will
switch from crutches to a cane at that time, and within a few
additional weeks will be fully weight bearing without assistive devices
(Fig. 30.12).

Complications
Most problems and complications from closed
intramedullary osteotomy of the femur can be avoided by following the
technical guidelines just discussed. Avoid inadequate correction of
deformity and inadequate fixation by good preoperative planning. Closed
intramedullary osteotomies are technically challenging and require
considerable experience with intramedullary nailing techniques. I
advise that the surgeon gain considerable experience with routine
fracture fixation using closed intramedullary nailing before attempting
these osteotomy techniques. Avoid comminution by not overreaming. I
have not had an infection or nonunion from closed shortening.
With shortening of less than 2.5 cm, muscle function
returns rather quickly. By Biodex measurement (Biodex Medical Systems,
Inc., Shirley, NY), most return to within a few percentage points of
normal (9). With shortening of more than 2.5
cm, at least 1 year is required to achieve 90% of normal muscle
function, and most patients are left permanently with about 5% of
residual weakness. In my patients, this has never been of functional
significance. Because union of the osteotomy is almost always present
by 6 weeks and quite mature at 12 weeks, the reestablishment of muscle
function and joint range of motion is the major determinant of return
to sports and vocational activities.
Because equalization of leg lengths is generally
performed in active patients, most will want the nails removed.
Although I have removed them as early as 9 months after surgery, I
advise most patients that removal is best delayed to 1 year.
Occasionally, a patient will develop some heterotopic
bone about the tip of the medullary nail that is symptomatic. Because
these patients are quite active, a nail that is left protruding will
also be symptomatic. In most cases, you can emphasize to patients that
you are operating on a normal extremity and that they will be left with
some residual disability, including a scar in the buttock, and that
some patients will have minor, long-term discomfort in the operative
site. This has discouraged none of my patients from having the surgery,
because the benefits of equal leg lengths far outweigh these minor
residuals.
Open Osteotomy with Intramedullary Nailing
Open osteotomy is technically much simpler than closed
osteotomy, but it has the disadvantage of slightly higher rates of
infection and nonunion. Before interlocking nails were available,
step-cut osteotomies were used to gain rotational control and better
stability. With locked nails, a step-cut osteotomy is not necessary. In
most instances, a straight transverse osteotomy can be used. When
angular deformity is present, a transverse osteotomy will result in an
open wedge-type osteotomy when the nail is driven.

P.967



Graft all osteotomies with the reamings and autogenous cancellous bone if necessary.

  • Place the patient on a fracture table as
    you would for the closed intramedullary nailing technique. Prepare and
    drape the entire thigh and buttocks area. Use a direct lateral approach
    (see Chapter 3) and expose the fracture site by subperiosteal dissection.
  • If length needs to be regained, take down the fracture site in a step-cut fashion (Fig. 30.13). Apply a femoral distractor or use traction on the fracture table to gain length.
    Figure 30.13. A:
    Malunion of a midshaft fracture of the femur with angulation and
    overriding. Even a year after the original fracture, the original
    cortex can be differentiated from the surrounding callus. To restore
    length, shave off the callus and identify the original cortex. Take
    down the malunion through the old fracture site. B: Apply an AO femoral distractor and restore alignment and length. Avoid excessive tension on the sciatic nerve. C:
    Fix the osteotomy with a 10- to 12-hole broad dynamic compression
    plate. Interfragmentary screw fixation is recommended. Apply the callus
    removed earlier as a bone graft. Add additional graft if necessary.
    (From Müller ME, Allgöwer M, Schneider R, Willenegger H. Manual of
    Internal Fixation. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1979, with permission.)
  • Align the femur and internally fix it
    with a locked intramedullary nail. Apply the reamings and/or a
    cancellous bone graft from the posterior ilium.
Postoperative care for open osteotomies with
intramedullary nailing is the same as for osteotomies using the closed
technique, as outlined previously. The complications are also the same.
Because there is a somewhat increased risk of infection due to open
technique, be certain to administer perioperative antibiotics.
SUPRACONDYLAR AREA
Osteotomy with Plate and Screw Fixation and Bone Grafting
Plate and screw fixation can be used for malunions of
the shaft but is most commonly used for condylar or supracondylar
malunions (1,6,29,32,34,39,42).
It may be necessary in malunions of the shaft where malalignment of the
medullary canal makes intramedullary nailing impossible. Many osteotomy
techniques are possible, including opening wedge, closing wedge,
step-cut, dome, and various types of oblique osteotomies. In most
cases, shortening, angulation, and malrotation must be corrected with a
single osteotomy. Closing-wedge osteotomies have the advantages of
simplicity and good stability. The disadvantages are that they result
in further shortening, and osteotomy site apposition is a problem when
correction of significant rotation is also required. Opening-wedge
osteotomies have the disadvantage of much less stability after fixation
and require structural bone grafting. Union is slower than with closing
wedge osteotomies, and remodeling of the graft is required. See Figure 30.13 for an illustration of open technique.
I prefer single-plane oblique osteotomies when treating
combination deformities, and the dome osteotomy for isolated varus or
valgus angulation in the metaphysis (33). An
oblique osteotomy has the advantages of excellent stability, broad bone
surfaces for union so that bone grafting is usually not required, and
correction of all components of the deformity. Disadvantages are that
considerable exposure of bone is required and meticulous preoperative
planning and surgical execution are necessary for it to work. In about
20 osteotomies in the distal femur, I have had one failure due to
nonunion, probably the result of overlengthening and devascularization
of the bone ends. The technique described next is an AO oblique
osteotomy for a supracondylar malunion (Fig. 30.14).
Figure 30.14. A:
AP radiograph of a malunion of the distal third of the femur in a
26-year-old athlete with 13° of varus, 15° of external rotation, and
1.5 cm of shortening. B: Preoperative lateral radiograph. C:
Tracing of the contralateral normal femur, and the osteotomy and
fixation planned for the malunion. A 12-hole plate and at least two
interfragmentary screws are planned for fixation. D:
Lateral tracing of the contralateral normal femur and the planned
correction for the malunion. Notice that the osteotomy is at 60° to the
transverse axis of the femur, which permits sliding to gain length.
(The wedge removed to correct the malrotation is not illustrated.) E: Intraoperative AP radiograph of the completed osteotomy. F: Lateral radiograph of the completed osteotomy.
Preoperative Planning
A frontal-plane or sagittal-plane osteotomy can be used;
in most cases the former is better. Make tracings of the preoperative
radiographs to determine the angular deformity to be corrected. Use
clinical measurements to determine the amount of malrotation to be
corrected. Use both clinical and radiographic assessments to determine
the length to be corrected. Make a drawing of the proposed
postoperative construct with internal fixation in place (Fig. 30.14A, Fig. 30.14B, Fig. 30.14C and Fig. 30.14D).
Technique
  • Place the patient in the supine position on the operating table. Prepare and drape the extremity to be operated

    P.968



    P.969



    on. In distal osteotomies, a tourniquet can be used. It is often useful
    to prepare and drape the contralateral normal extremity as well because
    this permits intraoperative comparison. Be certain that the pelvis is
    level so that leg-length determinations are accurate.

  • Expose the distal femur through an anterolateral approach (see Chapter 3).
    Place K-wires as guide pins in the proximal and distal segments. In the
    frontal plane, insert one K-wire in the distal fragment parallel to the
    knee joint. Insert a second wire into the proximal fragment at right
    angles to the shaft of the femur. Verify correct position by
    fluoroscopy or radiograph. Place a second set of K-wires in the
    sagittal plane, entering the anterior aspect of the femur. These are
    used to measure correction in the AP plane and can also be used to
    ascertain rotation. Place the wires at right angles to the knee joint
    distally and at right angles to the long axis of the femur in the
    proximal fragment. Put them in direct alignment with each other
    rotationally. Both of these sets of wires must be proximal and distal
    to the osteotomy site. Measure the distance between the anterior
    K-wires; this will be used to determine length.
  • Through the middle of the fracture site
    in the frontal plane, make an oblique osteotomy at 60° to the long axis
    of the femur. Begin distally on the anterior surface of the femur and
    exit posteriorly. Open the osteotomy site with bone-holding forceps or
    retractors. Next, remove a wedge of bone from the distal fragment. The
    base of the wedge will determine correction of rotation and any
    deformity in flexion or extension. Experienced surgeons can remove this
    with a single cut. Otherwise, take the wedge for correction of
    deformity in the sagittal plane first and then take a side-based wedge
    to correct rotation. Do not remove too large a wedge. It is better to
    take too small a wedge initially and then have to cut further. Accurate
    preoperative measurement, taking into account x-ray magnification, is
    necessary. Approximate the osteotomy site and slide the distal and
    proximal fragments against each other to correct varus or valgus
    angulation.
  • At this point, overall axial alignment of
    the femur is corrected and only shortening remains. Apply a Lowman
    bone-holding clamp or other bone-holding forceps to the osteotomy site
    to hold it in loose apposition. Apply a femoral distractor and slowly
    distract the osteotomy site to gain length. Keep the knee flexed and
    use other precautions to avoid excessive traction on the sciatic nerve,
    as described earlier in this chapter. Once enough length has been
    obtained, temporarily fix the osteotomy site with two or three large
    Steinmann pins. Carefully assess the correction clinically and
    radiographically to ensure it is adequate.
  • Begin internal fixation by inserting two
    or three anterior-to-posterior interfragmentary lag screws (either 6.5
    mm cancellous screws or cortical screws with gliding holes). Fixation
    depends on the location of the osteotomy and bone quality. The
    osteotomy will now be stable, which simplifies plate fixation. With an
    osteotome or saw, remove excessive bone from the edges of the osteotomy
    to restore the normal contours of the femur. Then apply a broad plate
    on the lateral surface of the femur and obtain at least eight cortices
    of screw fixation in both fragments (Fig. 30.14E, Fig. 30.14F).
    If the osteotomy is very distal, a condylar blade plate or
    distal-compression screw device may be necessary. Morcelize the bone
    removed from shaping the femur and pack it about the osteotomy site.
  • Release the tourniquet, if used, and secure hemostasis. Place two suction drains and close in the usual fashion.
Postoperative Care
Initially, apply a bulky soft dressing. As soon as the
patient is comfortable, remove the dressing and begin rehabilitation.
Continuous passive motion may be helpful in restoring knee motion.
Allow only touch-down weight bearing until union occurs.
During this period, progressive resistance exercises are possible as
long as the thigh is supported on the exercise table. Avoid excessive
weights. Because of the broad surfaces and intimate contact of the
osteotomy, union occurs rapidly. It may be difficult to document union
radiographically, however, because the osteotomy often appears healed
on the immediate postoperative film. Four routine views, as well as AP
and lateral tomograms, are often necessary to ascertain that union has
occurred. When it does occur, begin full weight bearing.
Crescentic (Dome) Osteotomy
The techniques for dome osteotomies are discussed in detail in Chapter 26. The following technique is used for isolated varus or valgus deformities of the femur in the supracondylar area (Fig. 30.15).
Figure 30.15. Crescentic (dome) osteotomy. AP radiograph (A)
of the right knee of a 42-year-old woman who has had moderately severe
genu valgum since she was a child. She was having significant lateral
compartment pain that interfered with her activities of daily living.
Bilateral radiographs showed moderately advanced arthritis of the
lateral compartment. She was treated with bilateral dome osteotomies;
this shows the right side. The black vertical line
on the lateral aspect of this radiograph shows the mechanical axis
between the center of the femoral head and the center of the ankle
joint, which here lies completely lateral to the joint. Note the tibial
femoral angle of 16° of valgus. AP (B) and lateral (C)
radiographs taken at the time of surgery show a dome osteotomy in the
distal femur with excellent correction of her deformity and restoration
of the mechanical axis to slightly medial of normal in order to unload
her lateral compartment. Note that the “cog wheel” edges of the
osteotomy are impacted and the osteotomy fixed with two
interfragmentary screws through a lateral plate. If any micromotion
exists in the osteotomy after this fixation, a small anterior plate can
be added as well. AP (D) and lateral (E)
radiographs taken after hardware removal approximately 2 years after
the initial osteotomy show good maintenance of alignment and good
preservation of the lateral joint space, with no evidence of
progression of her arthritis. At the 8-year follow-up, she continues to
do well with some evidence of progression of her arthritis. A similar
osteotomy was done of the opposite leg with an equally good result.
  • In the preoperative planning, be certain
    that a dome osteotomy will restore the normal mechanical axis of the
    knee, or if treating unilateral arthrosis that it will result in an
    appropriate shift of the mechanical axis.
  • Use a direct anterior midline incision by
    either an anteromedial or anterolateral approach depending on the
    deformity to be corrected and the fixation planned.
  • Perform the dome osteotomy using multiple drill points and an osteotome as described in Chapter 26.
    Make the osteotomy as distal as possible because this provides a larger
    area for the arc of the dome, which is technically easier and provides
    a broader surface area for union. Be certain to leave enough length in
    the distal fragment so that solid internal fixation with a lateral
    plate providing three bicortical screws of fixation in the distal
    fragment is possible.
  • After completing the osteotomy, correct
    the deformity, impact the osteotomy, and secure initial fixation with
    one or two interfragmentary screws across the osteotnomy.

    P.970



    Apply a broad plate laterally to provide neutralization, securing bicortical fixation with three screws distally and proximally.

  • Prior to closure, repeat mechanical axis
    determination with the fluoroscope to be certain that the goals of the
    osteotomy have been met.
  • Do a meticulous closure of the joint
    capsule and muscle, and apply a sterile dressing and knee immobilizer.
    Drain the knee and osteotomy site.
Patients can be mobilized from bedside to a chair on the
first postoperative day. As soon as the drain is removed, begin knee
range-of-motion and muscle rehabilitation exercises. These osteotomies
are very stable and most patients can begin 50% weight bearing with
assistive devices using a knee immobilizer immediately. Until the
osteotomy heals, avoid straight-leg raising and excessive stress across
the osteotomy site. Healing usually occurs in 6–8 weeks, at which time
progression to full weight bearing without assistive devices and afull
rehabilitation program can be instituted (Fig. 30.15A, Fig. 30.15B, Fig. 30.15C and Fig. 30.15D).

P.971


CONDYLAR AREA
Treatment of intra-articular malunions of the femoral
condyles is difficult. It is best to identify malposition early and
correct the deformity before remodeling takes place. Once remodeling
has occurred, it becomes exceedingly difficult to realign the articular
surfaces of the knee joint. Malunions of epiphyseal fractures in
children involving the condyles are even more difficult because the
malunion may be accompanied by growth arrest, and corrective osteotomy
often threatens the integrity of the physis. Specialized techniques are
necessary in children (see Chapter 168, Chapter 169, and Chapter 171).
Malunion of the lateral femoral condyle usually results
in valgus, external rotation, and flexion deformity. Malunion of the
medial condyle produces a similar deformity, but in varus. Most
disabling is the malrotation that interferes with the articular surface
of the patellar groove and produces malalignment of the patellar
mechanism. Comminuted fractures with a transverse component produce a
step-off in the articular surface that can interfere with patellar or
tibial motion on the femur. Although patients can walk fairly well with
the knee straight, function is impaired in flexion and during sports
activities.
Correction is difficult because restoration of a normal
articular surface is very difficult, and the amount of soft-tissue
stripping of the fragments necessary to restore them to proper position
risks avascular necrosis. Surgical techniques for medial and lateral
condyles are similar.
  • Place the patient in a supine position on
    the operating table and prepare and drape the entire extremity. As
    recommended previously, it may be advisable to drape the normal
    extremity as well for comparison. A tourniquet can be used.
  • Use an anteromedial or anterolateral
    parapatellar incision long enough so that the articular surfaces of the
    femur can be easily seen and complete access to the fracture site
    gained. To achieve good alignment, it is often necessary to dislocate
    the patella.
  • Maintain the soft-tissue attachments of
    the collateral ligaments, and as much joint capsule as possible, as
    well as the cruciate ligaments. In some distal femoral malunions, the
    femoral artery and vein are fibrosed to the posterior aspect of the
    femur. Dissect carefully in a subperiosteal manner along the posterior
    aspect of the femur, staying intimately against bone to avoid injury to
    the neurovascular structures. Keep the knee flexed

    P.972



    P.973



    to 90° during this dissection and when the osteotomy is made.

  • Identify the fracture site at the
    articular surface. With osteotomes, take down the malunion. Progress
    from the articular surface proximalward, attempting to stay in the old
    fracture site. A similar technique is used for transverse malunions.
  • With the condyle mobile, restore the
    alignment of the articular surface. Often this results in incongruity
    in the osteotomy or fracture site and requires some carpentry to obtain
    good alignment of the articular surface with good closure and
    apposition of the fracture and osteotomy site. Most difficult to
    correct is rotational malalignment.
  • Achieve temporary fixation with K-wires
    and obtain radiographs to ensure the correction is satisfactory.
    Internally fix the osteotomy with three or more interfragmentary 6.5 mm
    cancellous lag screws. In malunions, lag-screw fixation alone often is
    inadequate, and adding a plate to buttress the malunion is important.
  • When closing, ensure that the patella is
    in good alignment. Use suction drains and apply a bulky soft dressing
    with splints. A typical case is illustrated in Fig. 30.16
    Figure 30.16. A:
    AP radiograph of the left knee in a 28-year-old man with a healed
    fracture of the lateral tibial plateau and an intra-articular malunion
    of the lateral femoral condyle. B: Lateral radiograph showing a 15 mm offset in the articular surface of the lateral condyle of the femur due to the malunion. C:
    The malunion was taken down through the old fracture site with an
    osteotome inserted from the articular surface. This radiograph taken 2
    years after repair shows fixation with interfragmentary screws and a
    buttress plate. A bone graft was not necessary. D:
    Lateral view at 2-year follow-up. The articular surface is nearly
    anatomic. At 7-year follow-up, the patient was doing well and
    radiographs showed no degenerative changes.
Within 2 to 3 days postoperatively, remove the drains
and bulky dressing, and begin rehabilitation using continuous passive
motion. With solid internal fixation, an active rehabilitation program
is possible. Keep the patient on touch-down weight bearing until union
occurs. Again, multiplane radiographs and tomography may be necessary
to confirm union.
In some cases, there will be sufficient degenerative
changes in the knee that arthrodesis may be a better choice.
Arthrodesis of the knee is so disabling, however, that I usually advise
correction of the deformity followed by total knee arthroplasty.
NONUNIONS AND MALUNIONS OF THE PATELLA
NONUNIONS
Nonunions of the patella are unusual. They generally are
due to nonoperative treatment of widely displaced fractures or failure
of fixation, particularly as a result of infection. Treatment is
unnecessary unless the patient has symptoms. A fibrous union can have
acceptable function with minimal symptoms. Klassen and Trousdale (28)
treated 20 patients with patellar nonunions, of whom seven were treated
nonoperatively. They achieved an average knee range of motion of 120°
with a Knee Society score of 83 with a function score of 75. Pain, lack
of knee stability, or mechanical problems may require surgical
treatment. Therapeutic choices are total patellectomy, partial
patellectomy with repair of the quadriceps mechanism, or reconstruction
of the patella. In nonunions, it is difficult to correct the
irregularities in the patellar articular surface, so some type of
patellectomy is generally indicated. Reconstruction uses the same
principles of fixation and resection as described for patellar
fractures in Chapter 22. Use compression screw
fixation and a tension band wire. Bone graft is rarely necessary or
possible, but a sliding inlay graft can be used in some cases. Of the
13 patients Klassen and Trousdale (28) treated
operatively, all but one healed, achieving Knee Society scores of 94, a
function score of 93, and an average knee range of motion of 109°.
MALUNIONS
Malunions of the patella result in irregularities of the
articular surface. As with condylar fractures, correction is possible
but difficult. Joint-surface irregularity often persists. Total or
partial patellectomy may be the best choice. In active patients,
preservation of the patella is worthwhile, but do not allow persistent
incongruity of the articular surface to precipitate patellofemoral
arthritis or perhaps generalized arthritis in the knee.
  • The surgical technique is similar to that described for femoral condyle malunions. Use a long, medial parapatellar approach.
  • Invert the patella. Take down the malunion with osteotomes, working from the articular surface.
  • Realign the patella. Obtain solid fixation with interfragmentary lag screws and a tension band wire.
After surgery, maintain knee motion with continuous
passive motion and active assisted exercises. Judicious isometric
muscle exercises are beneficial. Avoid straight-leg raising. Permit
weight bearing with a knee immobilizer. Union will occur in 6–12 weeks.
Thereafter, institute a full rehabilitation program and allow gradual
return to normal activities.
REFERENCES
Each reference is categorized according to the following
scheme: *, classic article; #, review article; !, basic research
article; and +, clinical results/outcome study.
+ 1. Altenberg
AR, Shorkey RL. Blade-Plate Fixation in Nonunion and in Complicated
Fractures of the Supracondylar Region of the Femur. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1949;31:312.
+ 2. Ashby ME, Anderson JC. The Use of the Zickel Device for a Malunited Subtrochanteric Femur Fracture. JAMA 1977;69:623.

P.974


+ 3. Barquet
A, Silva R, Massaferro J, Dubra A. The AO Tubular External Fixator in
the Treatment of Open Fractures and Infected Nonunions of the Shaft of
the Femur. Injury 1988;19:415.
+ 4. Beall
MS Jr, Nebel E, Bailey RW. Transarticular Fixation in the Treatment of
Nonunion of Supracondylar Fractures of the Femur: A Salvage Procedure. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1979;61:1018.
+ 5. Beredjiklian
PK, Naranja RJ, Heppenstall RB, et al. Results of Treatment of 111
Patients with Nonunion of Femoral Shaft Fractures. Univ Penn Orthop J 1999;12:56.
+ 6. Boyd
HB, Lipinski SW, Wiley JH. Observations on Nonunion of the Shafts of
the Long Bones, with a Statistical Analysis of 842 Patients. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1961;43:159.
+ 7. Brav E. The Use of Intramedullary Nailing for Nonunion of the Femur. Clin Orthop 1968;60:69.
+ 8. Chapman MW. Closed Intramedullary Bone Grafting and Nailing of Segmental Defects of the Femur. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1980;62:1004.
+ 9. Chapman MW, Duwelius PJ, Bray TJ, Gordon JE. Closed Intramedullary Femoral Osteotomy. Clin Orthop 1993;287:245.
+ 10. Chapman MW, Finkemeier CG. Treatment of Supracondylar Nonunions of the Femur with Plate Fixation and Bone Graft. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1999;81:1217.
+ 11. Chapman MW, Pugh GA, Wood J, et al. Closed Intramedullary Nailing of Femoral Shaft Fractures. Orthop Trans 1982;6:326.
+ 12. Christensen NO. Shortening in Pseudarthrosis: Treatment with Küntscher Distractor. Acta Orthop Scand 1970;41:363.
+ 13. Christensen NO. Küntscher Intramedullary Reaming and Nail Fixation for Nonunion of Fracture of the Femur and the Tibia. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1973;55:312.
+ 14. Cove JA, Lhowe DW, Jupiter JB, Siliski JM. The Management of Femoral Diaphyseal Nonunions. J Orthop Trauma 1997;11:513.
+ 15. Esterhai
JL Jr, Brighton CT, Heppenstall RB, et al. Technetium and Gallium
Scintigraphic Evaluation of Patients with Long Bone Fracture Nonunion. Orthop Clin North Am 1984;15:125.
+ 16. Finkemeier CG, Chapman MW. Intramedullary Nailing of Femoral Diaphyseal Nonunions. Submitted, 1999.
+ 17. Fischer
D. Closed Shortening of the Femoral Shaft. Presented at the 39th annual
meeting of the Association of Bone and Joint Surgeons, Charleston,
South Carolina, 1987.
+ 18. Freedman
EL, Hak DJ, Johnson EE, Eckardt JJ. Total Knee Replacement Including a
Modular Distal Femoral Component in Elderly Patients with Acute
Fracture or Nonunion. J Orthop Trauma 1995;9:231.
+ 19. Hak
DJ, Lee SS, Goulet JA. The Success of Exchanged Reamed Intramedullary
Nailing for Femoral Shaft Nonunions. Presented to the Orthopaedic
Trauma Association, Vancouver, BC, Canada, October, 1998.
+ 20. Hamdy RC, Ehrlich MG. Subtrochanteric Derotation Osteotomy of the Femur Using Three or Four Wires. Clin Orthop 1994;302:111.
+ 21. Heppenstall RB. The Present Role of Bone Graft Surgery in Treating Nonunion. Orthop Clin North Am 1984;15:113.
+ 22. Johnson EE. Acute Lengthening of Shortened Lower Extremities after Malunion or Nonunion of a Fracture. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1994;76:379.
+ 23. Johnson EE, Urist MR. One-stage Lengthening of Femoral Nonunion Augmented with Human Bone Morphogenetic Protein. Clin Orthop 1998;347:105.
+ 24. Johnson
EE, Urist MR, Finerman GA. Bone Morphogenetic Protein Augmentation
Grafting of Resistant Femoral Nonunions. A Preliminary Report. Clin Orthop 1988;230:257.
+ 25. Kelly PJ. Infected Nonunion of the Femur and Tibia. Orthop Clin North Am 1984;15:481.
+ 26. Kettelkamp DB, Hillberry BM, Murrish DE, Heck DA. Degenerative Arthritis of the Knee Secondary to Fracture Malunion. Clin Orthop 1988;234:159.
+ 27. Kingsbury GH, Figgie HE III, Lacey SH, Figgie MP. Femoral Shaft Nonunion Treated by a Fluted Intramedullary Rod. Clin Orthop 1985;194:218.
+ 28. Klassen JF, Trousdale RT. Treatment of Delayed and Nonunion of the Patella. J Orthop Trauma 1997;11:188.
+ 29. Knight
JL, Ratcliffe SS, Weber JK, Hansen ST Jr. Corrective Osteotomy of
Femoral Shaft Malunion Causing Complete Occlusion of the Superficial
Femoral Artery: A Case Report. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1980;62:303.
* 30. Küntscher G. Die Marknagelung der Pseudarthose. Mschr Unfallheilk 1949;1:1.
+ 31. Matelic
TM, Monroe MT, Mast JW. The Use of Endosteal Substitution in the
Treatment of Recalcitrant Nonunions of the Femur: Report of Seven
Cases. J Orthop Trauma 1996;10:1.
* 32. Müller ME. Treatment of Nonunion by Compression. Clin Orthop 1965;43:83.
+ 33. Müller WE, Allgöwer M, Schneider R, Willenegger H. Manual of Internal Fixation. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1979.
+ 34. Müller ME, Thomas RJ. Treatment of Nonunion in Fractures of Long Bones. Clin Orthop 1979;138:141.
+ 35. Murray WR, Lucas DB, Inman VT. Treatment of Nonunion of Fractures of the Long Bones by the Two-Plate Method. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1964;46:1027.
* 36. Phemister DB. Splint Grafts in the Treatment of Delayed and Nonunion of Fractures. Surg Gynecol Obstet 1931;52:376.
* 37. Phemister
DB. Treatment of Ununited Fractures by Onlay Bone Grafts without Screw
or Tie Fixation and without Breaking Down on the Fibrous Union. J Bone Joint Surg 1947;29:946.
+ 38. Ring D, Jupiter JB, Sanders RA, et al. Complex Nonunion of Fractures of the Femoral Shaft Treated by Wave-plate Osteosynthesis. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1997;79:289.
+ 39. Rosen H. Compression Treatment of Long Bone Pseudarthroses. Clin Orthop 1979;128:154.
+ 40. Scott WA. Infected Nonunion of a Femur Treated with a Vascularized Fibular Graft. Injury 1985;16:455.

P.975


+ 41. Slätis P, Paavolainen P. External Fixation of Infected Nonunion of the Femur. Injury 1985;16:599.
# 42. Weber BG, Cech O. Pseudoarthrosis. Bern: Hans Huber, 1976.
+ 43. Weresh
MJ, Hakanson R, Stover M, et al. The Failure of Reamed Intramedullary
Exchange Nailing for Aseptic Ununited Femoral Shaft Fractures.
Presented to the Orthopaedic Trauma Association, Louisville, KY,
October, 1997.
+ 44. Winquist RA, Hansen ST Jr, Pearson RE. Closed Intramedullary Shortening of the Femur. Clin Orthop 1978;136:54.
+ 45. Wood MB. Femoral Reconstruction by Vascularized Bone Transfer. Microsurgery 1990;11:74.
+ 46. Wu CC, Chen WJ. Treatment of Femoral Shaft Aseptic Nonunions: Comparison between Closed and Open Bone-grafting Techniques. J Trauma 1997;34:112.
+ 47. Zickel RE. An Intramedullary Fixation Device for the Proximal Part of the Femur: 9 Years’ Experience. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1976;58:866.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More